Tweedledum, Tweedledee, and the Crow

Alan Marley • November 18, 2026
Tweedledum, Tweedledee, and the Crow | Alan Marley
Politics

Tweedledum, Tweedledee, and the Crow

Schumer and Jeffries are no Nancy Pelosi, and the party they are about to lead is five parties in a trench coat

Alan Marley · November 18, 2026 · 12 min read

Lewis Carroll gave us two round, identical men who agreed to have a battle over a spoiled rattle, dressed up like walking junk piles, and then ran off screaming when a monstrous crow flew overhead. I have been waiting years for Washington to produce a cast that fits the story better than Chuck Schumer and Hakeem Jeffries. Congratulations, Democrats. Casting is complete.

The Cast

In Carroll’s version, Tweedledum and Tweedledee are twins. They finish each other’s thoughts, they hold hands, they get dressed for war with bolsters and saucepans, and they never actually fight anyone. The whole production is ceremony. Alice, who is the only sensible person in the scene, watches the pair of them and wonders why anyone takes this seriously.

Now picture the Democratic leadership. Schumer in the Senate has led his caucus since 2017. [4] Jeffries in the House inherited the job from Nancy Pelosi. They are two New Yorkers with matching talking points, matching press conferences, and a matching habit of announcing that this time they will fight. They stood side by side on the Senate steps in May with the rest of the congressional Democrats, a photograph that could have been lifted from the book. [10]

I am not saying they are the same man. I am saying that when one of them says something, you can write the other one’s statement before lunch.

The Rattle

The fight in Carroll’s poem is over a rattle. In Washington the rattle is a gavel, and the two men have it, or are about to.

Democrats won the midterms. [11, 28] A normal party would spend a week enjoying that. The Democrats spent it fighting over who gets to hold the rattle.

On the Senate side, Schumer has been busy defending his own job. Bernie Sanders and Elissa Slotkin, who agree on almost nothing, announced they will not support him for leader. [27] Chris Van Hollen has urged colleagues to “withhold commitments” until Schumer lays out a vision, and Slotkin said Democrats should not give him a quorum until he answers their concerns. [28] Senators-elect have said the same, including Annie Andrews, who wants “generational change.” [27] Semafor reported that the Schumer-aligned Senate Majority PAC and its affiliates spent $67 million in Michigan, $65 million in Maine, and $14 million in Kansas, and the senators those states sent to Washington say they do not support him. [7]

Read that again. Money from Schumer’s own allies bought him senators who say they will not vote for him.

On the House side, Jeffries has a nominating vote today. He has no declared challenger and needs only a simple majority of House Democrats, so he will almost certainly get through it. [25] But Reuters reports that incoming progressives are using the vote to register their discontent. Representative-elect Adam Hamawy said, “We’re not going to rubber-stamp anything.” Protesters heckled Jeffries at the party’s Denver conference, and a draft-Ayanna Pressley effort has collected more than 150,000 signatures. [30]

Notice the pattern. Neither man has a serious rival. Both men are being treated by their own side as problems to be managed. That is a leader who wins the vote and loses the room.

Nobody Here Is Nancy Pelosi

Neither of these two is Nancy Pelosi, and the Democrats are about to find out how much that matters.

You can despise Pelosi’s politics. Her record is her record. She was the first woman to serve as Speaker, held the gavel from 2007 to 2011 and again from 2019 to 2023, and passed the Affordable Care Act. CBS described her influence over House Democrats as widely seen as unusually strong. [22] Her caucus did not hold a vote and then spend the afternoon on cable news explaining why it might not mean it. When Pelosi counted votes, the count held.

Give her this much: even she could not remove Trump. She impeached him twice, and Senate Republicans acquitted him both times. [21] Strength did not guarantee a win. But strength got her a caucus that moved together while the other side watched.

Jeffries and Schumer are inheriting the title and not the grip. Pelosi leaves Congress when her term ends in early 2027. [23] The woman who held the herd is walking out the door just as the herd gets bigger, louder, and more convinced it deserves to be in charge.

Five Parties in a Trench Coat

The Democratic Party is not one party anymore. It is at least five, and every one of them wants something the others hate. Here is the cast, with the names and the demands.

The Socialists. NPR counts six Democratic Socialists of America candidates elected to the House, which would grow the DSA’s House membership fourfold once the new Congress is seated. [1] Add Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Rashida Tlaib, and the bloc is eight. Their platform is Medicare for All, abolishing ICE, and an arms embargo on Israel, and their leaders say they will withhold support from Democratic leadership until their demands are met. [12] Incoming Rep. Claire Valdez, one of the newcomers, put the strategy in a sentence: every piece of leverage needs to be on the table. [17] Washington Examiner reports that DSA also backs abolishing the Electoral College and replacing the Supreme Court with a new judiciary subordinate to Congress. [19] These people did not come to Washington to compromise with Chuck Schumer. They came to collect.

The Progressives. Bernie Sanders wants everything, and he has written it down. His list: Medicare for All, an annual 5% wealth tax on billionaires, a $20 minimum wage, expanded Social Security, free tuition at public colleges and at medical and nursing schools, universal child care, 7 million affordable homes, and a moratorium on AI data centers. [2] After the election he added ending the war in Iran and ending U.S. military aid to Israel. [8] The wealth tax pays for all of it, he says, including a $12,000 direct payment to a family of four. [26] He titled his post-election demand “No more excuses,” and he is not writing to Republicans. He is writing to Schumer and Jeffries. Sanders has already announced he will not back Schumer for leader. [27] Congressional Progressive Caucus chair Greg Casar says voters delivered a demand for bold change and that Medicare for All should move forward. [5, 15] Jeffries, meanwhile, has taken heat from the left for backing away from Medicare for All. [32] That is a promise the progressives intend to cash.

The Old School. This is the Schumer wing, and it believes the party’s job is to manage the crowd, not obey it. In 2025 Schumer joined Republicans to prevent a government shutdown, and two weeks later Democrats were still fuming over how he handled the standoff. [5] That is the old guard’s idea of a fight, and half the caucus has not forgiven it. Pelosi, who held this wing together by force of will, leaves Congress in early 2027. [23] Even within this wing, the old reflexes are shifting. Jim Clyburn, a lion of the old guard, has said he supports expanding the Supreme Court. [9] When the establishment’s own elder statesmen are talking about changing the Court, you are not looking at a wing that can rein anything in.

The Centrists. Every faction on the left has a rival on the right. Elissa Slotkin, who agrees with Sanders on almost nothing, announced she will not support Schumer and said Democrats should deny him a quorum until he answers their concerns. [27, 28] Mark Kelly says he will support Schumer but wants the caucus to do things differently. [28] In the House, the Problem Solvers Caucus, the Blue Dog Coalition, and the New Democrat Coalition are watching the left flank and waiting for a weak leader to give them more room. [32] The size of the House majority helps Jeffries here. Axios reports Democrats are on track to win more than 250 seats, enough to blow up the plan of the progressive Bloc to extract concessions for its votes, and TIME says Jeffries appears poised to pass legislation without unanimous support from either wing. [15, 17] Fine. That solves the speaker vote. It does not solve the 435 votes after it, each of which is a negotiation between a left that wants it all and a center that wants none of it.

The New Radicals. These are the ones with the long list of structural demands. Abdul El-Sayed, the Michigan senator-elect, won his race with 52% of the vote, and he has said he will not vote for Schumer and would back a challenge from Chris Van Hollen. [13] His signature is Medicare for All, funded by a billionaire wealth tax. [20] He has said he would happily name the program after Trump if Trump would sign it, and that passing it would be worth it just to make the president veto it on the record. [29] He has also called the filibuster anti-democratic, which tells you what he plans to do with Senate rules the minute he gets a vote. [14] Kamala Harris, the party’s most recent presidential nominee, says Democrats should revisit the Electoral College, revisit expanding the Court to 13 justices, and revisit statehood for Puerto Rico and D.C. [19] Ocasio-Cortez and Ro Khanna have come out in favor of court expansion. [31] Even Jeffries is in the mix: the Wall Street Journal reported, according to Townhall, that he has signaled support for expanding the Court, imposing 18-year term limits, and changing Senate rules to make it possible. [3, 24] Schumer himself said in 2020 that “nothing is off the table.” [6]

Put it together. The socialists want leverage. Sanders wants the whole shopping list. The old guard wants peace. The centrists want to be left alone. The radicals want to rewrite the Court, the Electoral College, and the filibuster. Schumer and Jeffries have to hold these five together with a rattle and a smile.

Five factions, one gavel. That is not a coalition. That is a hostage situation with a seating chart.

A Gift to Trump and the Republicans

Here is the part Republicans will not say out loud, because they do not need to. Schumer and Jeffries are the best thing that has happened to Trump and the GOP in years.

Both men are ineffective. Neither has the respect of anyone in Washington. The right does not fear them. The left does not trust them. The center tolerates them. Their own senators and House members are lining up to withhold support, hold press conferences about withholding support, and collect signatures on petitions to replace them. A leader whose own caucus treats him as a problem to be managed cannot threaten anyone across the aisle.

Republicans do not have to beat these two. They have to wait. Every time Schumer announces a strategy, Republicans can bet that Sanders, Slotkin, or a senator-elect will announce a different one by dinner. Every time Jeffries makes a promise, Republicans can bet that the bloc will tell reporters it has not decided whether to believe him. A negotiating partner who cannot deliver his own votes is worth nothing at the table, and everyone at the table knows it.

Trump knows it better than anyone. He built a career on sizing up the man across from him. He will look at Schumer and see a leader who lost the room before the first meeting. He will look at Jeffries and see a Speaker who needs a faction’s permission to say yes. That is not an opponent. That is leverage.

The Crow

Carroll’s poem ends the way every pointless argument should. A monstrous crow, black as a barrel of tar, swoops over the two warriors, and the two warriors forget the quarrel and bolt for cover.

The crow is Donald Trump, and he will not need to be monstrous. He just needs to be disciplined, which he has been for a decade, while his opposition spends its energy on itself.

Think about how a negotiation with this White House works. Trump has a single vote count to manage: the Republican side. Schumer and Jeffries have to manage a left that thinks compromise is betrayal, a center that thinks confrontation is suicide, and a caucus full of newcomers who ran against the leadership. Every concession they offer comes with a revolt behind it. Every show of strength comes with a faction ready to call it a sellout.

A counterpart who cannot deliver his own side is not a counterpart. He is an obstacle with good manners. If I were across the table, I would not need to outwork them. I would need to wait for the next caucus leak.

I do not say this with joy. I wrote not long ago that a House majority is not a license, and that gridlock cannot be the whole plan. Divided government is supposed to force the two sides to bargain. But bargaining requires someone who can say yes and make it stick, and I cannot name the person on the other side who can.

The Bottom Line

Tweedledum and Tweedledee at least had each other. The Democratic leaders have each other and five factions pulling in five directions. The crow does not have to be scary. He just has to show up.

Pelosi is leaving, and she is leaving behind a party that depended on her. Schumer and Jeffries are the men who inherit it. Alice watched the twins prepare for battle and decided the whole thing was a waste of her time. I suspect a lot of American voters are about to feel the same way.

References
  1. 6 DSA candidates are elected to the House in a historic night for their movement. (2026, November 3). NPR. npr.org/2026/11/03/g-s1-150034/2026-midterm-election-dsa-candidates
  2. Bernie Sanders tells Democrats ‘guess again’ if they plan to ‘tinker around the edges’ ahead of 2026 midterms. (2026). Benzinga. benzinga.com/node/62428763
  3. Chalfant, J. (2026, August 16). Democrats are coming for the Supreme Court. Townhall (reporting the Wall Street Journal). townhall.com/news/josephchalfant/2026/08/16/democrats-are-coming-for-the-supreme-court-n2681325
  4. Chuck Schumer faces Senate Democrat rebellion over leadership bid. (2026, November 9). Fox News. foxnews.com/politics/schumers-grip-power-slips-dems-begin-revolt-against-him-eye-new-leadership
  5. Democrats concede they have no alternative to Chuck Schumer for now. (2025). Yahoo News. yahoo.com/news/schumer-keeps-job-democrats-wonder-084500116.html
  6. Democrats eye expanding Supreme Court if Trump’s nominee is confirmed. (2020). CBS News. cbsnews.com/news/democrats-supreme-court-packing-trump-nominee-confirmed-election
  7. Democrats mire themselves in Schumer debate after landslide win. (2026, November 12). Semafor. semafor.com/article/11/12/2026/democrats-mire-themselves-in-schumer-debate-after-landslide-win
  8. Democrats must deliver, Bernie Sanders says after sweeping midterm gains. (2026, November 8). Common Dreams. commondreams.org/news/democrats-must-deliver-bernie-sanders
  9. Democrats plan to destroy the Supreme Court. (2026, October). Washington Examiner (opinion). washingtonexaminer.com/op-eds/4784624/court-packing-supreme-court-independence/
  10. Democrats won big. Now they’re fighting over who leads. (2026, November 16). The Daily Signal. dailysignal.com/2026/11/16/democrats-election-leadership-fighting-leads/
  11. Division among US Democrats over Schumer’s leadership role. (2026, November 5). Al Jazeera. aljazeera.com/news/2026/11/5/division-among-us-democrats-over-schumers-leadership-role
  12. DSA celebrates ‘Socialist Surge’ after midterms, but large Dem majority means less influence. (2026, November 10). Just the News. justthenews.com/government/congress/dsa-celebrates-socialist-surge-after-midterms-large-dem-majority-means-less
  13. El-Sayed and four other Democratic senators-elect will not vote for Schumer as leader. (2026, November). VOZ. voz.us/en/politics/261106/1000371/el-sayed-and-four-other-democratic-senators-elect-will-not-vote-for-schumer-as-leader.html
  14. El-Sayed enters race for Michigan’s U.S. Senate seat. (2025, April 17). Michigan Advance. michiganadvance.com/2025/04/17/el-sayed-enters-race-for-michigans-u-s-senate-seat/
  15. House Democrats face epic power struggle over their massive majority. (2026, November 5). Axios. axios.com/2026/11/05/house-democrats-jeffries-centrists-majority-left
  16. Inside the Democrats’ plans to take on Trump. (2026, November 4). TIME. time.com/article/2026/11/04/democrats-power-midterms/
  17. Kamala Harris signals support for abolishing Electoral College and expanding Supreme Court. (2026). Washington Examiner. washingtonexaminer.com/news/4671719/kamala-haris-abolish-electoral-college-expand-supreme-court/
  18. LaForge, J. (2026, November 4). How Abdul El-Sayed would build Medicare for All, from a wealth tax to a Fed-style governing board. Fortune. fortune.com/2026/11/04/el-sayed-medicare-for-all-plan-senate-michigan/
  19. Nancy Pelosi first woman to serve as US House speaker to retire from Congress. (2025, November). The Standard (Reuters). thestandard.com.hk/world/article/316170/Nancy-Pelosi-first-woman-to-serve-as-US-House-speaker-to-retire-from-Congress
  20. Nancy Pelosi, former House speaker, to retire from Congress after this term. (2025, November 6). CBS News. cbsnews.com/amp/miami/news/nancy-pelosi-former-house-speaker-retire-congress
  21. Nancy Pelosi, former House speaker, to retire from Congress after this term. (2025, November 6). CBS News. cbsnews.com/news/nancy-pelosi-former-house-speaker-retire-congress
  22. Newly empowered Democrats could revive plans for court reforms. (2026, November 6). Yahoo News. yahoo.com/news/politics/articles/democrats-could-dust-off-plans-110006471.html
  23. Popli, N. (2026, November 18). Hakeem Jeffries on track for speaker nomination in Wednesday vote. TIME. time.com/article/2026/11/18/hakeem-jeffries-picked-by-democrats-first-black-speaker-of-the-house
  24. Sanders, B. (2026, November 14). No more excuses: Democrats must deliver. Fox News. foxnews.com/opinion/sen-bernie-sanders-excuses-democrats-deliver.print
  25. Sanders, Slotkin won’t back Schumer as Senate Democratic leader. (2026, November). The Hill. thehill.com/homenews/6211705-sanders-slotkin-oppose-schumer/
  26. Schumer faces skepticism among some Democrats over majority leader role. (2026, November 7). CNN. cnn.com/2026/11/07/politics/senate-democrats-new-majority-leader
  27. Sen.-elect Abdul El-Sayed on bold action and Van Hollen. (2026, November). Common Dreams. commondreams.org/news/abdul-el-sayed-van-hollen
  28. Speaker vote gives progressive Democrats a chance to vent at Hakeem Jeffries. (2026, November 18). Reuters (via U.S. News). usnews.com/news/politics/articles/2026-11-18/speaker-vote-gives-progressive-democrats-a-chance-to-vent-at-hakeem-jeffries
  29. The one issue to rule them all. (2026). The Nation. thenation.com/article/politics/supreme-court-2028-election-democrats/
  30. The progressive revolt stops at Hakeem Jeffries. (2026). The Lever. levernews.com/the-progressive-revolt-stops-at-hakeem-jeffries/
Disclaimer: This article reflects the personal opinions of the author and is offered for commentary and public discourse purposes only. It does not represent the positions of any institution, employer, organization or affiliated entity. It is political commentary.
Alan Marley, DBA
Writer · Professor · alanmarley.com
By Alan Marley • November 18, 2026
By Alan Marley • November 17, 2026
By Alan Marley • November 15, 2026
By Alan Marley • November 15, 2026
By Alan Marley • November 15, 2026
By Alan Marley • November 14, 2026
By Alan Marley • November 11, 2026
By Alan Marley • November 10, 2026
By Alan Marley • November 8, 2026
Show More