Polarizing is not the same as guilty. It is also not the same as bigoted. Amber Givens, the former Dallas County district judge who takes office as the county’s district attorney in January, is polarizing. Her conduct drew real complaints, a state commission disciplined her, and a special court threw out every charge. Her defenders say race and gender explain the hostility toward her. Her critics say her behavior explains it. The evidence supports a narrower conclusion than either side wants: she was a divisive judge who drew more scrutiny than the record ultimately supported, and nothing in the public record shows that race or gender is the reason.
I wanted to examine this because two habits in political discourse trouble me. One is condemning someone before the evidence has been examined. The other is treating a claim of bias as obviously true or obviously false before anyone has examined that either. Givens’s case tests both.
Three Claims, Not One
Most arguments about Givens collapse three separate claims into one. The first is that her conduct drew criticism. The second is that the criticism produced discipline that was justified. The third is that the criticism was driven by her race or gender.
Each claim needs its own evidence. The record supports the first, undercuts the second, and is silent on the third.
What the Record Shows About Her Conduct
The complaints began with the Dallas Criminal Defense Lawyers Association, which alleged poor judicial temperament and described her as aggressive, condescending, and disrespectful toward attorneys. [6] The Texas Observer reported complaints of “belittling” treatment of defense attorneys. [18] It also described a June 2020 hearing in which Givens told an assistant district attorney to change her tone and then lectured her. A former prosecutor who worked in her courtroom said she stopped trying cases there because she did not want to be “harassed” or “patronized” again. [18]
That is a picture of condescension and lecturing. I found no account of shouting or outbursts.
The conflict was also unusually large. In 2022, 15 defense attorneys sought to remove her from more than 100 cases, arguing they could not get fair trials. [6] The region’s administrative judge said he had never seen that many recusals in one county, and the Observer reported that prosecutors joined defense attorneys in criticizing her courtroom behavior. [18]
Then there is the 2021 survey of the Dallas Criminal Defense Lawyers Association, which rated judges on temperament, communication, and impartiality. Givens received the lowest overall score: 9.6 out of 30, or 32% of the available points, and only slightly more than half that of the next-lowest judge. The published reporting does not give the survey’s response rate. [18] Those categories are subjective, so the score measures perception, not proof. It is still a meaningful signal from the lawyers who took part.
Even the court that cleared her described her as “certainly a polarizing individual.” [14]
None of this is a finding of misconduct. These are complaints and perceptions. But they came from more than one group, which makes it hard to dismiss the whole thing as a campaign by a single faction.
The Discipline Did Not Survive Review
In June 2025, the Texas State Commission on Judicial Conduct publicly reprimanded and admonished Givens. [15] The allegations included allowing her court coordinator to run a Zoom bond hearing while appearing to act as the judge, treating attorneys without patience, dignity, and courtesy, mishandling recusal motions, and acting in two cases after she had been removed from them. Givens said she had computer trouble and joined the hearing by phone. The Texas Rangers investigated the Zoom hearing, and the Kaufman County District Attorney’s Office declined to bring criminal charges. [10]
Givens appealed. On July 16, 2026, a three-judge Special Court of Review dismissed every charge. [13, 14]
Precision matters here. The ruling was not a technicality. The court held a new hearing, heard 14 witnesses, and concluded the commission had not proven the allegations by a preponderance of the evidence. It found inconsistencies in the testimony that were understandable given the time that had passed, and it noted the shortcomings of the clerk’s software, which made it hard for a judge to know whether a recusal had been filed or granted. [14]
That last point bears on the jailing allegations. According to the commission’s admonition, Givens acknowledged ordering two defendants jailed without authority after she had been recused. [5] Her explanation was the software. The special court did not find the conduct was intentional.
Does the ruling mean Givens did nothing wrong? No. A finding that charges were not proven does not establish that every disputed event never happened. It means the evidence was insufficient to support discipline.
It cuts both ways. It would be unfair to keep calling her a judge with established violations when those findings were overturned. It would be just as wrong to say the ruling erased every complaint about her courtroom. The commission’s charges failed. The complaints that led to them were not imaginary.
Is Criticizing Givens Racist or Sexist?
Some of her defenders believe she faced disproportionate scrutiny because she is a Black woman. That possibility should not be dismissed automatically. There are accounts of people commenting on her hairstyle, appearance, and mannerisms, and those comments have no bearing on whether someone can administer justice. [18]
Givens has made a specific claim of her own. She says the defense lawyers association’s complaints followed an anti-discrimination policy she created after an attorney posted racist comments on social media in the wake of George Floyd’s murder. [7] Her defenders’ case deserves to be stated in full, so here it is.
Ed Gray, an activist and radio host, laid it out in the Dallas Weekly in 2022. He argues that Givens pushed an anti-discrimination provision into the Dallas District Court Plan, which governs how attorneys are appointed to represent indigent defendants, after lawyers posted comments calling Black protesters “animals” and “savages.” Those lawyers, he says, belonged to the defense lawyers association and took court appointments, so the policy threatened their assignments and income. His claim is that the association answered with a calculated campaign: more than 100 recusal motions alleging she was biased, and grievances to a state commission he calls Republican-dominated. He places all of it in a longer history of Black women in Dallas County courts facing hostility, including over their hair and age. [9]
KOLUMN Magazine makes a related point from another angle. It argues that a narrative about Givens formed and traveled through complaints, disciplinary proceedings, news reports, and lawyers’ conversations before the evidence was heard, and it says plainly that criticism of a Black female judge is not inherently racist or sexist. [2]
That argument has real strengths. It names a motive, a mechanism, and a timeline that can be checked. A claim that specific can be tested. It also has limits. Gray’s column is opinion, and its claims about the association’s motives are his characterizations, not findings. It offers no evidence of how the commission handled the grievances. And it has a harder time explaining the prosecutors who, according to the Observer, joined the complaints about her courtroom behavior. [18] The association’s own complaints, as reported, were about temperament and her treatment of attorneys. [6] I did not find the association’s response to the policy claim. So far, on that point, it is her side’s account against theirs.
Here is where I come down. Judgments about temperament are subjective, and subjective judgments are exactly where bias can enter. Whether a woman or a Black judge gets labeled “difficult” can reflect expectations as much as behavior. That is a fair thing to say, and it does not prove anything about this case.
A criticism does not become racist merely because its subject is Black. It does not become sexist because its subject is female.
Allegations of discrimination need evidence too, and so do dismissals of them. Audra Riley, another Black female judge, scored 28.2 out of 30 in the same survey. [18] One rating cannot settle anything either way.
The record neither shows bias nor rules it out.
Scrutiny That Outran the Evidence
The clearest example of Givens being singled out came outside the courtroom. In September 2025, Dallas County commissioners voted to give every district judge a $25,000 pay supplement except Givens. She sued, and commissioners paid her the following month. [11]
Commissioners alluded to her state sanctions but did not explicitly cite them as the reason. [10] Those sanctions were in force at the time and are an obvious explanation. They were also later dismissed.
I cannot tell you whether the snub reflected bias, dislike, or a reaction to the sanctions. What I can say is that it rested on findings that did not hold up. That is what scrutiny outrunning the evidence looks like, and it does not require race or gender to explain it.
Who Elected Her?
The district attorney is elected countywide, as was Givens in her judicial seat. The Census Bureau puts Dallas County at roughly 2.66 million residents, about 22.3% of them Black, with large Hispanic and White populations as well. [19]
A precinct-level analysis of the March 2026 Democratic primary found that she built a coalition across Black, Hispanic, and White communities, particularly in middle-income areas. Incumbent John Creuzot did better in several more affluent, predominantly White communities. [3] Her victory was not carried by any single group.
Givens defeated two-term District Attorney John Creuzot in the primary. [4, 16]
| Candidate | Vote share | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Amber Givens | 54% | 134,615 |
| John Creuzot | 46% | 115,482 |
Creuzot was an established incumbent with considerable prosecutorial experience, and Givens carried considerable controversy into the race. Democratic primary voters chose her anyway. It is reasonable to read part of that as dissatisfaction with Creuzot, though an election cannot tell us why each voter chose as they did. Givens emphasized community justice, transparency, and diversion programs, and Creuzot’s office had drawn criticism over particular prosecutorial decisions. [4]
No Republican appeared on the November ballot. Givens won the general election against a write-in challenger, which made the primary the decisive contest. [1, 17]
The voters who knew about the controversy chose her. Whatever the legal establishment thought of her, the electorate that mattered did not share it.
Can She Run the District Attorney’s Office?
My greatest concern is not her race, her gender, or even the controversy over her disciplinary proceedings. It is whether she can manage one of Texas’s major prosecutorial offices.
Givens has substantial courtroom experience from her years as a district judge. But serving as a judge and directing a large prosecutorial organization are different jobs. According to the Texas Observer, Givens has not prosecuted a felony case in Dallas County. [17] That does not automatically disqualify her. Executive leadership requires organizational judgment, the ability to hire competent people, and sound administrative decisions. But the experience gap is a fair subject for public debate.
The staffing reports are more concerning. In November 2026, the Texas Observer reported that 77 employees had left the district attorney’s office since the March primary, with additional resignations pending. The office reportedly had 49 vacancies. [1, 17]
Not every departure can be pinned on Givens. Some employees leave for ordinary career reasons, and leadership transitions create uncertainty. Still, a large exodus of experienced personnel creates obvious challenges. Prosecutors manage complicated cases, and institutional knowledge and continuity matter. If experienced attorneys leave faster than they can be replaced, the public may eventually feel it through delayed proceedings and diminished prosecutorial capacity.
That concern holds regardless of who won the election.
The Public Deserves Results, Not Excuses
I have little patience for the idea that criticizing a public official automatically proves bigotry. I have equally little patience for ignoring an official’s successful legal defense because we dislike the person.
Givens takes office in January 2027. We should judge her by measurable results.
Does she retain and recruit qualified prosecutors?
Does the office manage its criminal caseload effectively?
Are cases handled promptly and competently?
Does she build productive working relationships with defense attorneys, judges, and law enforcement?
Does she maintain appropriate professional standards?
Does her administration earn public confidence through actual performance?
These are reasonable expectations for anyone entrusted with prosecutorial authority. They are not racist. They are not sexist. They are the ordinary standards of public accountability.
My Conclusion: Polarizing Is Not the Same as Guilty
Here is what the record supports. Givens was a divisive judge whose conduct drew complaints from more than one group. The charges built on those complaints did not hold up. Some of the scrutiny she drew went beyond what the evidence supported. And nothing in the public record shows that her race or gender is the reason.
I am reluctant to assume her critics were motivated by race or gender, and equally reluctant to assume they were not. Each claim requires evidence, just as allegations of professional misconduct do. I am also unwilling to treat the dismissal of the charges as proof that every complaint was baseless.
Givens asked Dallas County voters to entrust her with an enormously important responsibility, and they agreed. Now she has to show that their confidence was justified.
- 77 employees quit Dallas County DA’s office as Democrat Amber Givens prepares to become top prosecutor. Black Enterprise (summarizing the Texas Observer report). blackenterprise.com/dozens-quit-dallas-county-da-office-amber-givens/
- Before the evidence spoke, Amber Givens had already been judged. (2026, July 19). KOLUMN Magazine. kolumnmagazine.com/2026/07/19/before-the-evidence-spoke-amber-givens-had-already-been-judged/
- Chronicles of a Dallas County Democrat. March 2026 Democratic election results in Dallas County. chroniclesofadallascountydemocrat.com
- Dallas County DA loses reelection bid. (2026, March 4). Axios Dallas. axios.com/local/dallas/2026/03/04/dallas-county-da-john-creuzot-amber-givens-primary
- Dallas district judge sanctioned twice. (2025, July). Texas Scorecard. texasscorecard.com/local/dallas-district-judge-sanctioned-twice/
- Dallas judge sanctioned over allegations she made staff impersonate her at online hearing. (2025, July 3). The Dallas Morning News. dallasnews.com/news/courts/2025/07/03/dallas-judge-sanctioned-over-allegations-she-made-staff-impersonate-her-at-online-hearing/
- Embattled judge Amber Givens challenges District Attorney John Creuzot in primary. (2025, December 4). The Dallas Morning News. dallasnews.com/news/elections/2025/12/04/embattled-judge-amber-givens-challenges-district-attorney-john-creuzot-in-primary/
- Gray, E. (2022, September). In defense of Judge Amber Givens of Dallas County. Dallas Weekly (opinion). dallasweekly.com/2022/09/in-defense-of-judge-amber-givens-of-dallas-county/
- Judge Amber Givens challenges Dallas County District Attorney John Creuzot for top prosecutor role. (2025, December 4). KERA News. keranews.org/government/2025-12-04/judge-amber-givens-challenges-dallas-county-district-attorney-john-creuzot-for-top-prosecutor-role-democratic-election
- Judge who sued Dallas County will get $25,000 pay supplement. (2025, October 7). KERA News. keranews.org/news/2025-10-07/judge-amber-givens-sued-dallas-county-will-get-paid-25-000-supplement
- Sanctions dismissed against former judge, Dallas County District Attorney-elect Amber Givens. (2026, July 17). KERA News. keranews.org/government/2026-07-17/sanctions-dismissed-against-former-judge-dallas-county-district-attorney-elect-amber-givens
- Special Court of Review. (2026, July 16). In re Inquiry Concerning Honorable Amber Givens, Docket No. SCR 25-0002. scjc.texas.gov/media/lwljg0fq/scr-25-0002-opinion-issued-givens-07-16-26.pdf
- State Commission on Judicial Conduct. (2025, June 23). Public reprimand and public admonition of Judge Amber Givens. (Document not located online; cited from reporting by The Dallas Morning News , July 3 and 7, 2025.)
- Texas Election Results. (2026). 2026 Democratic primary election. Dallas County District Attorney.
- Texas Observer. (2026, November 3). Controversial ex-judge will officially be Dallas’ top prosecutor. texasobserver.org
- Texas Observer. Inside a bizarre case of (alleged) judicial impersonation in Dallas. texasobserver.org/who-judges-the-judges/
- U.S. Census Bureau. QuickFacts: Dallas County, Texas. census.gov/quickfacts










