Every time the stock market hits a new high, political leaders—especially sitting presidents—rush to take credit. “Under my leadership,” they boast, “the economy is booming!” Financial news outlets repeat the headlines, talking heads speculate, and social media lights up with celebratory charts. But before we break out the champagne, we need to ask a few harder questions:
Why are stocks actually up?
Why do presidents obsess over it?
And most importantly—does it matter to the average American?
Let’s break it down.
Why Stocks Are Up
The stock market doesn’t just rise because the economy is strong. It rises based on
expectations—of growth, profit, stability, or policy. Today’s rally is driven by several intertwined factors:
The AI Boom and Tech Optimism:
Investors are betting big on the future of artificial intelligence. Tech giants like NVIDIA, Microsoft, and Alphabet are seeing record valuations as they invest in machine learning, cloud computing, and generative AI tools. This optimism is pushing the Nasdaq and S&P 500 to new heights, with tech stocks leading the charge (CNBC, 2024).
Interest Rate Expectations:
The Federal Reserve plays a massive role. When the Fed signals a pause or cut in interest rates, borrowing becomes cheaper for companies and consumers, encouraging investment and spending. In 2024, expectations of future rate cuts sparked multiple market rallies (Federal Reserve, FOMC Minutes, 2024).
Corporate Earnings and Cost-Cutting:
Many publicly traded companies have reported earnings that beat analysts’ expectations—not always because they’re selling more, but because they’ve aggressively cut costs, streamlined operations, or raised prices without losing customers. These “efficiency gains” look great on Wall Street (Bloomberg, 2024).
Resilient Consumer Spending:
Even with stubborn inflation, Americans are still spending, particularly on services and travel. That supports corporate revenues and delays fears of a full-blown recession.
But here’s the problem: Wall Street’s success doesn’t always translate to Main Street’s well-being.
Why Presidents Obsess Over the Market
The stock market is easy political currency.
A surging S&P 500 provides a
simple, visible narrative that a president can use to claim economic competence.
Unlike GDP reports or inflation stats—which are complex and lagging—the market offers a real-time scoreboard. Whether it’s Reagan-era “morning in America” or Trump’s tweetstorms about record highs, presidents use the market as a branding tool.
And let’s be real: they only talk about it when it’s up. When markets fall—as they did during the early days of COVID or during recessions—administrations pivot quickly, blaming external events, past leadership, or “market overreaction.”
Presidents don’t move markets directly—but policies like tax cuts, deregulation, stimulus packages, and spending priorities can influence investor sentiment. The market’s rise becomes a form of political validation, even if the credit is misplaced.
Does the Stock Market Matter to the Average American?
Yes and no.
Yes, if you have a 401(k), IRA, pension fund, or own mutual funds, you benefit when the market rises. As of 2023, about
58% of Americans own some form of stock—mostly through retirement accounts (Gallup, 2023). If you're middle class with a diversified portfolio, a good year on Wall Street could grow your retirement nest egg.
No, because stock ownership is highly concentrated. According to the
Federal Reserve’s Survey of Consumer
Finances, the top 10% of Americans hold nearly 89% of all U.S. stocks (Federal Reserve, 2022). That means most gains go to the already-wealthy. If you’re living paycheck to paycheck, market records feel like noise.
Also: Short-term market booms don’t necessarily mean wage growth, job security, or affordable housing. A record-high Dow doesn’t lower your grocery bill or pay your car insurance.
Is the Stock Market a Rich Man’s Game?
Let’s not sugarcoat it—in many ways, yes.
Wall Street remains dominated by institutional investors, hedge funds, and high-frequency traders. These players have access to data, algorithms, and political influence that everyday investors can’t match. They drive most of the volume and profit from the system’s complexity.
However,
democratization is happening slowly. The rise of:
- Index funds (like Vanguard or Fidelity)
- Commission-free trading (Robinhood, Schwab)
- Fractional shares
- Employer-sponsored retirement plans
...means middle-class Americans have more access than ever. But access isn’t the same as
equity of influence. The rich can weather volatility and play long-term. The rest of us are often just along for the ride.
Conclusion: A Mirror, Not a Measure
The stock market reflects investor
sentiment, not national reality. It can be optimistic while the economy struggles. It can crash while job numbers stay strong. It is a mirror of market confidence, not a measure of household well-being.
Presidents cling to it because it’s symbolic. Voters hear “record highs” and assume all is well. But ask yourself: if stocks are up, but your rent, groceries, and gas are higher too—what’s really improving?
The stock market is not irrelevant. But it’s not everything.
Next time you see a chart with a red arrow pointing skyward, ask: is that a win for you—or just a celebration for them?
References
